There are few people who more renowned in the Chasidic movement of Judaism than Rabbi Nachman of Breslov (1772-1810). Chasidic Jews are called Hasidim in Hebrew. This word derived from the Hebrew word for loving kindness (chesed). The Chasidic movement is unique in its focus on the joyful observance of God’s commandments (mitzvot), heartfelt prayer, and boundless love for God and the world He created. Many ideas for Hasidism derived from Jewish mysticism (Kabbalah).
The movement originated in Eastern Europe in the 18th century, at a time when Jews were experiencing great persecution. While the Jewish elite focused on and found comfort in Talmud (Jewish law) study, the impoverished and uneducated Jewish masses hungered for a new approach.
Fortunately for the Jewish masses, Rabbi Israel ben Eliezer (1698-1760) found a way to democratize Judaism. He was a poor orphan from Opoky, Ukraine. As a young man, he traveled around to various Jewish villages, healing the sick, and helping the poor. After he married, he went into seclusion in the mountains and focused on mysticism. As his following grew, he became known as the Baal Shem Tov (abbreviated as Besht) which means “Master of the Good Name”.
In a nutshell, the Baal Shem Tov led European Jewry away from reliance upon rabbis and toward mysticism. The early Chasidic movement encouraged the poor and oppressed Jews of 18th century Europe to be less academic and more emotional, less focused on executing rituals and more focused on experiencing them, less focused on gaining knowledge and more focused on feeling exalted. The way one prayed became more important than one’s knowledge of the prayer’s meaning. The Baal Shem Tov did not modify Judaism, but he did suggest that Jews approach Judaism from a different psychological state.1
The great-grandson of the Baal Shem Tov, Rabbi Nachman of Breslov (sometimes called Bratzlav, Breslau, or Bratislava) was one of the most creative, influential, and profound of the Chasidic masters and the founder of the Breslover Chasidic sect. Breslov is a town in Ukraine where Rabbi Nachman spent the end of his life, but some say the name Breslov comes from the Hebrew bris lev, meaning "covenant of the heart."
From his youth, he followed a path of asceticism and prayer, though he warned his followers not to abuse themselves physically. He emphasized living life with joy and happiness. One of his best-known sayings is, "It is a great mitzvah (blessing) to be happy."
He was a passionate individual, given to intense swings of emotions. These he put toward the service of God, and spoke often of how to find God even in the low states of mind, and how to serve Him during the emotional highs.
Central to his teachings is the role of the tzaddik (righteous person), who has the power to descend into the darkness to redeem lost souls; the path of prayer as the main expression of religious life. His main work is Likutey Moharan, composed partly by himself, partly by his chief disciple, Rabbi Nosson Sternhartz (1780-1844). The book is a collection of sermons delivered by Rabbi Nachman, given mostly on the holidays when his Chassidim gathered. The lessons are long and complex, masterfully drawing on the entire body of Talmud, Midrashic and Kabbalistic literature. Ideas are connected by a poetic and intuitive grasp of the texts. In addition, Rabbi Nachman wrote thirteen “Tales” — mythical stories of kings and wizards based upon Kabbalistic thought and capturing the essence of Rabbi Nachman’s teachings. These tales were known to have influenced later authors such as Franz Kafka (1883-1924).
Rabbi Nachman died of Tuberculosis at the age of 38. Despite the fact that there was never another “Breslov Rebbe” to fill his place, the mystery and depth of his teachings continue to attract students today, and Breslover Chassidism is one of the largest and most vibrant of Chassidic groups.2
When people think of Ukraine in regard to religion, they would normally think of the Orthodox Church; however, Odessa has always had a very large Jewish community. Members of the Jewish community from Russia, Ukraine, and most other countries are part of the Ashkenazic sect. Ashkenaz is the Hebrew name for “Germany”, but this sect is not limited to Germany.
The Chasidim are known as “the chosen ones”. This sect of Judaism is not popular with many Jewish people who are not Orthodox Jews. Kabbalah, Jewish mysticism, is a very interesting part of the Jewish tradition. Orthodox Christianity, Roman Catholicism, and Islam all have a mystical tradition as part of their faith. I would recommend A Still Small Voice by Rabbi Nachman as an example of his teaching. This small book is a collection of his most famous sayings.
In accordance with the custom of his time, he was married at the age of 13 soon after becoming Bar Mitzvah. His wife was Sashia, daughter of Rabbi Ephraim of Ossatin, from a village near the town of Medvedevka. In their 22 years of marriage they had eight children, but four - including two sons - died in childhood. Four daughters survived, with known descendants until today.
From the time of his marriage Rabbi Nachman lived in Ossatin with his father-in-law, continuing his studies and devotions until he attained unique levels of sanctity and holy spirit as well as being fully conversant with the entire array of Biblical, Talmudic, Halachic, Midrashic and Kabalistic literature. At first he was unknown to all except one disciple five years his senior, Rabbi Shimon ben Baer, who attached himself to him shortly after his marriage and became his life-long follower.
At the age of 18 Rabbi Nachman left his father-in-law's home to live in Medvedevka, where he spent the next ten years. It was there that his greatness first became revealed, and he rapidly gained an ardent following including some distinguished scholars and Kabbalists and the octogenarian Rabbi Yekusiel, the Magid of Terhovitz, one of the senior leaders of the Chassidic movement. Rabbi Nachman emphasized faith, prayer and ever-renewed spiritual growth. As a result of his practice of hearing the personal confessions of his adherents, they were originally known as the Viduynikers - Confessors. 3
The influence of Rabbi Nachman is still alive in the Chasidic community today. This is proof that his teachings were timeless. It is interesting that a Jewish leader from Ukraine could have so much influence of Jewish people world-wide two hundred years after he died.
End Notes
1) “Ultra-Orthodox Judaism” http://judaism.about.com/od/denominationsofjudaism/a/hasid.htm (accessed 5/14/12)
2) “Rabbi Nachman of Beslov” http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/biography/Nachman.html (accessed 5/14/12)
3) “The Essential Rabbi Nachman” http://azamra.org/Essential/life.htm (accessed 5/14/12)
Tuesday, May 15, 2012
Sunday, May 13, 2012
The Poor Will Always be with Us
Every culture has its own unique qualities. The culture of the United States is largely a blend of many different cultures since we are a nation of immigrants. With the exception of Brazil, most countries in South America were very heavily influence by Spanish culture. Brazil was heavily influenced by Portuguese culture. The nations of the former Soviet Union are strongly influenced by Orthodox culture and their connection to the Orthodox Church. This is quite obvious in the novels of the classic Russian authors.
While these various nations have their own uniqueness, the one thing that all of them have in common is that each nation has poor people. The poor are often not even notice by those who have more money. They are “invisible” people. This was true in the late 19th century and is still true today.
In 1845, Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoevsky (1821-1881) wrote his first novel entitled Poor Folk. This novel was written prior to his imprisonment. It was while he was in prison that he underwent a major conversion experience. He became a supporter of the czar and developed a great respect for the peasantry. This also seemed to be the beginning of his involvement in the Slavophile movement.
The novel was originally published in A Petersburg Collection published. One anecdote states that the journal’s editor, Nikolai Nekrasov, declared “A new [Nikolai] Gogol has arisen!” Many literary critics, including Vissarion Belinsky, also gave this work much acclaim rocketing Fyodor Dostoevsky to literary fame.1
It is put together in the form of a set of letters written between two people, Makar Devushkin and Varvara Dobroselova. Makar and Varvara are second cousins twice-removed and live across from each other on the same street in terrible apartments. Makar’s, for example, is merely a portioned-off section of the kitchen, and he lives with several other tenants, such as the Gorshkovs, whose son dies and who groans in agonizing hunger almost the entire story, gently crying at night. Makar and Varvara exchange letters back and forth attesting to their terrible living conditions and the former frequently squanders his money on gifts for the latter.
The reader progressively learns about their history throughout the story. Varvara used to live in the country until her father lost his job, and then she moved into St. Petersburg, which she hates. Her father was very violent after losing his job and her mother became severely depressed. He dies and they move in with Anna Fyodorovna, a landlady who was previously cruel to them but at least pretends to feel badly for their situation. There Varvara is tutored by a poor student named Pokrovsky, whose drunken father occasionally visits. She eventually falls in love with him. She struggles to save a measly amount of money to purchase Pokrovsky the complete works of Pushkin at the market for his birthday present, and then allows his father to give the books to him, claiming that just his receipt of the books will be enough for her happiness. Povrovsky falls ill soon after, and his last dying wish is to see the sun and the world outside, which Varvara obliges by opening the blinds to grey clouds and dirty rain. In response he only shakes his head and then passes away. His father runs after the coffin during the procession, with some of his son’s books falling in the mud as he goes along alone in the rain.
Varvara's mother dies soon after, and she is left in the care of Anna for a time, but eventually goes out on her own because of the abuse to live with Fedora across the street. Makar works as a lowly copyist, frequently belittled at his job and picked on. His clothing is worn and dirty, and his living conditions are perhaps worse than Varvara's. He considers himself a rat in society. As he and Varvara exchange letters (and occasional visits that are never detailed), they begin to exchange books. Makar becomes offended when she sends him a copy of The Overcoat, because he finds the main character to be living the life he now lives.
Varvara considers leaving to another part of the city where she can work as a governess, but in a spot of luck, when Makar is completely out of money and may possibly be thrown out by his landlady, he comes upon 100 rubles. It happens that he miscopies a document and is brought to the head at his office, who tells him he can still copy it again and after looking at his terrible condition gives him the money so he can buy himself new clothes. He pays off his debts and sends some to Varvara, who sends him 25 rubles back because she doesn’t need all of it, and the future looks bright for the both of them because he can now start to save up money and they can possibly move in together.
Suddenly, all of the rumors about Varvara marrying a drunk become meaningless in the face of money. Makar finds himself liked by even the writer Ratazyayev, who was using him as a figure in one of his stories because of his sad condition. Even the Gorhkovs come across money because the father’s case is won in court. With the considerable sum they seem perfectly happy, but he dies soon after anyway, leaving his family in shambles despite the money. Soon after this Varvara announces that a Mr. Bykov, who had dealings with Anna Fyodorovna and Pokrovsky’s father, has proposed to her. She decides to leave with him and the last few letters attest to her slowly becoming used to her new money.
She has Makar find linen for her and begins to talk about various luxuries, leaving him alone in the end despite the fact that he was coming on to better times. The story ends with a final letter from him written in a desperate plea for her to come back to him or at least write from her new life. 2
Poor Folk is an epistolary novel -- that is, a tale told as a series of letters between the characters. And oh, what characters these are Makar Dievushkin Alexievitch is a copy writer, barely squeaking by; Barbara Dobroselova Alexievna works as a seamstress, and both face the sort of everyday humiliation society puts upon the poor. These are people respected by no one, not even by themselves. These are folks too poor, in their circumstances, to marry; the love between them is a chaste and proper thing, a love that brings some readers to tears. But it isn't maudlin, either; Fyodor Dostoevsky has something profound to say about these people and this circumstance. And he says it very well. When the book was first published a leading Russian literary critic of the day -- Vissarion Belinsky (1811-1848) -- prophesied that Dostoevsky would become a literary giant. It isn't hard to see how he came to that conclusion, and in hindsight, he was surely was correct.
The male protagonist is the first in a long line of Dostoevskyian anti-heroes, undergound men, figures of such extreme marginality that even they are not sure whether they exist: He’s a man with a reputation what am I? Compared to him, I simply don’t exist…, an ontological uncertainty which Dostoevsky picked up from his reading of Hoffman, and which he was to develop more fully in the later tale The Double. Makar Devushkin lives behind a screen in the kitchen and works as a copyist: he has no space or original contribution of his own. His character comes to life only in and through his letters; he writes himself, creates himself through writing, and exists only in the dialogue with Varvara: when I got to know you, I began for a start to know myself better…before you came along, I was as good as asleep, I wasn’t really living in the world at all… when you came my way, you lit up the whole of my dark life so that my mind and soul were illuminated …When she leaves Petersburg to marry Bykov, the dialogue stops, Devushkin disappears, and the book ends.
He also displays the irrational behavior which was Dostoevsky’s contribution to the philosophical picture of man. When he retrieves his button from under the feet of his boss, to his own horror, he acts against his own best interest: had I not been such a fool I would have stood to attention and kept still. But oh, no: I began pressing the button against the torn off threads, as though that would make it stay on and what’s more, I smiled and smiled again. The drunken episodes, the getting into debt for Varvara’s sake are also forms of irrational behaviour. His Dostoevskyan irascibility; however, is mediated by a tenderness towards Varvara and towards the world, a tenderness which is not present in the later loners of the Dostoevsky canon.
The novel is as much about literature as about the urban poor. Much of the plot revolves around the acquisition of books, there are constant references to other literature: grammars, style manuals, Pushkin, excerpts from the (terrible) writings of Devushkin’s friend and hero, Mr Ratazyayev. The whole tale can be read as Dostoevsky’s dialogue with the overwhelming power of Gogol. The characters lend each other books and comment on them. Devushkin lives in fear of being lampooned in a feuilleton (Dostoevsky himself lampoons another one of his marginal folk in the darkly hilarious tale Mr. Prokharchin, where even the narrator calls the eponymous hero a fool). Although Devushkin knows he is a marginal being, he nonetheless has a fully developed sense of amour propre and is quick to take umbrage. The epistolary nature of this novel is a kind of tact on Dostoevsky’s part, in allowing these marginal characters to speak for themselves with their own voices, without the presence of a narrator to describe them, to falsify them or to mock them.
Devushkin is struck by a quote from a style manual which is a kind of manifesto for the group around Ratazyayev: Literature is a picture, or, rather, in a certain sense, both a picture and a mirror: it is an expression of emotion, a subtle form of criticism, a didactic lesson and a document. This may also stand as a manifesto, not only for the method and subject of Poor Folk, but indeed for Dostoevsky’s entire career: the Christian didacticism of his later novels, the expressionism of his confessional stance, his picture of underground and marginal types, his criticisms of society, nihilism and other forms of philosophy, and the mirror he holds up to the modern soul.
The characters which Dostoevsky introduces us to are not unique and can be placed in almost any culture; however, how the individuals deal with their situation is directly related to their culture. These people are Russian and are quite familiar with daily sufferings. Their connection to the Orthodox Church helps many Russians, both ancient and modern, to find hope in their suffering and united these sufferings to those of Jesus Christ.
In my article “The Beauty of the Russian Soul”5 I spoke about the influence of Orthodox culture has on the Russian soul. The Russian soul is not simply limited to those who live in Russia, but to people from Ukraine, Belarus, and various other nations where Orthodox Christianity is the predominant religion.
Fyodor Dostoevsky’s genius can be found in all of his novels. On a personal level, he felt very connected to the poor even though his father was a medical doctor. He spent much of his life impoverished, which is not uncommon among most artists, so he understood the experiences of the poor.
End Notes
1) “Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Biography” http://www.egs.edu/library/fyodor-dostoevsky/biography/ (accessed 5/12/12)
2) “Poor Folk” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poor_Folk (accessed 5/12/12)
3) “Poor Folk” http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/67326.Poor_Folk (accessed 5/12/12)
4) “Poor Folk: Dostoevsky” http://thelectern.blogspot.com/2008/12/poor-folk-dostoevsky.html (accessed 5/13/12)
5) “Beauty of the Russian Soul” http://heideggerm1.blogspot.com/2011/10/beauty-of-russian-soul.html
While these various nations have their own uniqueness, the one thing that all of them have in common is that each nation has poor people. The poor are often not even notice by those who have more money. They are “invisible” people. This was true in the late 19th century and is still true today.
In 1845, Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoevsky (1821-1881) wrote his first novel entitled Poor Folk. This novel was written prior to his imprisonment. It was while he was in prison that he underwent a major conversion experience. He became a supporter of the czar and developed a great respect for the peasantry. This also seemed to be the beginning of his involvement in the Slavophile movement.
The novel was originally published in A Petersburg Collection published. One anecdote states that the journal’s editor, Nikolai Nekrasov, declared “A new [Nikolai] Gogol has arisen!” Many literary critics, including Vissarion Belinsky, also gave this work much acclaim rocketing Fyodor Dostoevsky to literary fame.1
It is put together in the form of a set of letters written between two people, Makar Devushkin and Varvara Dobroselova. Makar and Varvara are second cousins twice-removed and live across from each other on the same street in terrible apartments. Makar’s, for example, is merely a portioned-off section of the kitchen, and he lives with several other tenants, such as the Gorshkovs, whose son dies and who groans in agonizing hunger almost the entire story, gently crying at night. Makar and Varvara exchange letters back and forth attesting to their terrible living conditions and the former frequently squanders his money on gifts for the latter.
The reader progressively learns about their history throughout the story. Varvara used to live in the country until her father lost his job, and then she moved into St. Petersburg, which she hates. Her father was very violent after losing his job and her mother became severely depressed. He dies and they move in with Anna Fyodorovna, a landlady who was previously cruel to them but at least pretends to feel badly for their situation. There Varvara is tutored by a poor student named Pokrovsky, whose drunken father occasionally visits. She eventually falls in love with him. She struggles to save a measly amount of money to purchase Pokrovsky the complete works of Pushkin at the market for his birthday present, and then allows his father to give the books to him, claiming that just his receipt of the books will be enough for her happiness. Povrovsky falls ill soon after, and his last dying wish is to see the sun and the world outside, which Varvara obliges by opening the blinds to grey clouds and dirty rain. In response he only shakes his head and then passes away. His father runs after the coffin during the procession, with some of his son’s books falling in the mud as he goes along alone in the rain.
Varvara's mother dies soon after, and she is left in the care of Anna for a time, but eventually goes out on her own because of the abuse to live with Fedora across the street. Makar works as a lowly copyist, frequently belittled at his job and picked on. His clothing is worn and dirty, and his living conditions are perhaps worse than Varvara's. He considers himself a rat in society. As he and Varvara exchange letters (and occasional visits that are never detailed), they begin to exchange books. Makar becomes offended when she sends him a copy of The Overcoat, because he finds the main character to be living the life he now lives.
Varvara considers leaving to another part of the city where she can work as a governess, but in a spot of luck, when Makar is completely out of money and may possibly be thrown out by his landlady, he comes upon 100 rubles. It happens that he miscopies a document and is brought to the head at his office, who tells him he can still copy it again and after looking at his terrible condition gives him the money so he can buy himself new clothes. He pays off his debts and sends some to Varvara, who sends him 25 rubles back because she doesn’t need all of it, and the future looks bright for the both of them because he can now start to save up money and they can possibly move in together.
Suddenly, all of the rumors about Varvara marrying a drunk become meaningless in the face of money. Makar finds himself liked by even the writer Ratazyayev, who was using him as a figure in one of his stories because of his sad condition. Even the Gorhkovs come across money because the father’s case is won in court. With the considerable sum they seem perfectly happy, but he dies soon after anyway, leaving his family in shambles despite the money. Soon after this Varvara announces that a Mr. Bykov, who had dealings with Anna Fyodorovna and Pokrovsky’s father, has proposed to her. She decides to leave with him and the last few letters attest to her slowly becoming used to her new money.
She has Makar find linen for her and begins to talk about various luxuries, leaving him alone in the end despite the fact that he was coming on to better times. The story ends with a final letter from him written in a desperate plea for her to come back to him or at least write from her new life. 2
Poor Folk is an epistolary novel -- that is, a tale told as a series of letters between the characters. And oh, what characters these are Makar Dievushkin Alexievitch is a copy writer, barely squeaking by; Barbara Dobroselova Alexievna works as a seamstress, and both face the sort of everyday humiliation society puts upon the poor. These are people respected by no one, not even by themselves. These are folks too poor, in their circumstances, to marry; the love between them is a chaste and proper thing, a love that brings some readers to tears. But it isn't maudlin, either; Fyodor Dostoevsky has something profound to say about these people and this circumstance. And he says it very well. When the book was first published a leading Russian literary critic of the day -- Vissarion Belinsky (1811-1848) -- prophesied that Dostoevsky would become a literary giant. It isn't hard to see how he came to that conclusion, and in hindsight, he was surely was correct.
The male protagonist is the first in a long line of Dostoevskyian anti-heroes, undergound men, figures of such extreme marginality that even they are not sure whether they exist: He’s a man with a reputation what am I? Compared to him, I simply don’t exist…, an ontological uncertainty which Dostoevsky picked up from his reading of Hoffman, and which he was to develop more fully in the later tale The Double. Makar Devushkin lives behind a screen in the kitchen and works as a copyist: he has no space or original contribution of his own. His character comes to life only in and through his letters; he writes himself, creates himself through writing, and exists only in the dialogue with Varvara: when I got to know you, I began for a start to know myself better…before you came along, I was as good as asleep, I wasn’t really living in the world at all… when you came my way, you lit up the whole of my dark life so that my mind and soul were illuminated …When she leaves Petersburg to marry Bykov, the dialogue stops, Devushkin disappears, and the book ends.
He also displays the irrational behavior which was Dostoevsky’s contribution to the philosophical picture of man. When he retrieves his button from under the feet of his boss, to his own horror, he acts against his own best interest: had I not been such a fool I would have stood to attention and kept still. But oh, no: I began pressing the button against the torn off threads, as though that would make it stay on and what’s more, I smiled and smiled again. The drunken episodes, the getting into debt for Varvara’s sake are also forms of irrational behaviour. His Dostoevskyan irascibility; however, is mediated by a tenderness towards Varvara and towards the world, a tenderness which is not present in the later loners of the Dostoevsky canon.
The novel is as much about literature as about the urban poor. Much of the plot revolves around the acquisition of books, there are constant references to other literature: grammars, style manuals, Pushkin, excerpts from the (terrible) writings of Devushkin’s friend and hero, Mr Ratazyayev. The whole tale can be read as Dostoevsky’s dialogue with the overwhelming power of Gogol. The characters lend each other books and comment on them. Devushkin lives in fear of being lampooned in a feuilleton (Dostoevsky himself lampoons another one of his marginal folk in the darkly hilarious tale Mr. Prokharchin, where even the narrator calls the eponymous hero a fool). Although Devushkin knows he is a marginal being, he nonetheless has a fully developed sense of amour propre and is quick to take umbrage. The epistolary nature of this novel is a kind of tact on Dostoevsky’s part, in allowing these marginal characters to speak for themselves with their own voices, without the presence of a narrator to describe them, to falsify them or to mock them.
Devushkin is struck by a quote from a style manual which is a kind of manifesto for the group around Ratazyayev: Literature is a picture, or, rather, in a certain sense, both a picture and a mirror: it is an expression of emotion, a subtle form of criticism, a didactic lesson and a document. This may also stand as a manifesto, not only for the method and subject of Poor Folk, but indeed for Dostoevsky’s entire career: the Christian didacticism of his later novels, the expressionism of his confessional stance, his picture of underground and marginal types, his criticisms of society, nihilism and other forms of philosophy, and the mirror he holds up to the modern soul.
The characters which Dostoevsky introduces us to are not unique and can be placed in almost any culture; however, how the individuals deal with their situation is directly related to their culture. These people are Russian and are quite familiar with daily sufferings. Their connection to the Orthodox Church helps many Russians, both ancient and modern, to find hope in their suffering and united these sufferings to those of Jesus Christ.
In my article “The Beauty of the Russian Soul”5 I spoke about the influence of Orthodox culture has on the Russian soul. The Russian soul is not simply limited to those who live in Russia, but to people from Ukraine, Belarus, and various other nations where Orthodox Christianity is the predominant religion.
Fyodor Dostoevsky’s genius can be found in all of his novels. On a personal level, he felt very connected to the poor even though his father was a medical doctor. He spent much of his life impoverished, which is not uncommon among most artists, so he understood the experiences of the poor.
End Notes
1) “Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Biography” http://www.egs.edu/library/fyodor-dostoevsky/biography/ (accessed 5/12/12)
2) “Poor Folk” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poor_Folk (accessed 5/12/12)
3) “Poor Folk” http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/67326.Poor_Folk (accessed 5/12/12)
4) “Poor Folk: Dostoevsky” http://thelectern.blogspot.com/2008/12/poor-folk-dostoevsky.html (accessed 5/13/12)
5) “Beauty of the Russian Soul” http://heideggerm1.blogspot.com/2011/10/beauty-of-russian-soul.html
Saturday, May 12, 2012
The Man Behind the Curtain
One of the most popular US films for both
adults and children is “The Wizard of Oz”.
This 1939 film is an adaption of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz written by
L. Frank Baum (1856-1919) in 1900. The
film is one of the first movies to be filmed in color (a brand new technology
in 1939). The first part of the film was
film in black and white, the majority was filmed in color, and the end of the
film was filmed in black and white.
As a children’s story, the premise is very simple. Kansas farm girl Dorothy Gale lives with her Aunt Em, Uncle Henry, and three farm hands, Hickory, Hunk, and Zeke. When Miss Almira Gulch is bitten by Dorothy's pet Cairn Terrier, Toto, she gets a sheriff's order and takes him away to be destroyed. He escapes and returns to Dorothy, who, fearing for his life, runs away with him.
Dorothy soon encounters a traveling fortune teller named Professor Marvel, who guesses she has run away and tells her fortune. He convinces her to return home by falsely telling her that Aunt Em has fallen ill from grief. With a tornado fast approaching, she rushes back to the farmhouse, but is unable to join her family in the locked storm cellar. Taking shelter inside the house, she is knocked unconscious by a window frame blown in by the twister.
Dorothy awakens to find the house being carried away by the tornado. After it falls back to earth, she opens the door and finds herself alone in a strange village. Arriving in a floating bubble, Glinda, the Good Witch of the North, informs her that her house landed on and killed the Wicked Witch of the East.
The timid Munchkins come out of hiding to celebrate the Witch's demise by singing "Ding-Dong! The Witch Is Dead". Their celebration is interrupted when the Wicked Witch of the West (Miss Gulch) suddenly appears in a cloud of smoke and tries to claim her dead sister's powerful ruby slippers. However, Glinda magically transfers them onto Dorothy's feet and reminds the Witch of the West that her power does not work in Munchkinland. She promises Dorothy "I'll get you, my pretty...and your little dog, too!" before leaving the same way she arrived. When Dorothy asks how to get back home, Glinda advises her to seek the help of the mysterious Wizard of Oz in the Emerald City, which she can reach by following the Yellow Brick Road, and warns her never to remove the ruby slippers or she will be at the mercy of the Wicked Witch.
On her way to the city, Dorothy meets a Scarecrow (Hickory), a Tin Man (Hunk), and a Cowardly Lion (Zeke), who lament to her that they respectively lack a brain, a heart, and courage. The three decide to accompany her in hopes that the Wizard will also fulfill their desires, although they demonstrate that they already have the qualities they believe they lack: the Scarecrow has several good ideas, the Tin Man is kind and sympathetic, and the Lion, though terrified, is ready to face danger.
After Dorothy and the Cowardly Lion nearly succumb to one of the Witch's traps, the quartet enters the Emerald City and is allowed to see the Wizard, who appears amidst smoke and flames as a disembodied, intimidating head. In a booming voice, he states that he will consider granting their wishes if they bring him the Wicked Witch's broomstick.
They set out for the Witch's castle, but she detects them and dispatches her army of flying monkeys, who carry Dorothy and Toto back to her. When the Witch threatens to drown Toto, Dorothy agrees to give up the ruby slippers, but a shower of sparks prevents their removal. Realizing they can't be removed unless Dorothy dies, the Witch leaves to ponder how to accomplish this.
Toto escapes and leads Dorothy's companions to the castle. After overpowering some of the Winkie guards and disguising themselves in their uniforms, they find and free her. The Witch and the Winkies corner the group on a parapet, where she sets the Scarecrow's arm ablaze with her broomstick. Dorothy throws water on her friend and accidentally splashes the Witch, causing her to melt. The Winkies are delighted, and their captain gives Dorothy the broomstick.
Upon their triumphant return to the Wizard's chamber, Toto opens a curtain, revealing him to be an ordinary man (Professor Marvel) operating a console of wheels and levers while speaking into a microphone. Apologetic, he explains that Dorothy's companions already possess what they have been seeking all along, but bestows upon them tokens of esteem in recognition of their respective virtues. Explaining that he too was born in Kansas, and was brought to Oz by a runaway hot air balloon, he offers to take Dorothy home in the same balloon, leaving the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Lion in charge of the Emerald City.
As they are about to leave, Toto jumps out of the balloon's basket and Dorothy runs after him. The Wizard, unable to control the balloon, leaves without her. As she despairs of ever getting back home, Glinda appears and tells her that she always had the power to return home, but that she needed to learn for herself that she didn't have to run away to find her heart's desire. She bids her friends goodbye, then follows Glinda's instructions to close her eyes, tap her heels together three times, and keep repeating "There's no place like home".
Dorothy awakens in her bedroom in Kansas, surrounded by family and friends, and tells them of her journey. Although Auntie Em assures her it was all a dream, Dorothy insists it was real, especially since she saw all the people she knows in the Land of Oz, and promises never to run away from home again.1
There are some differences between this film and the original novel. For example, in the novel, Dorothy’s slippers were silver, not ruby. Also, Glinda, the good witch, was actually a collection of three characters in the novel. This film appears on US television annually and has been popular with numerous generations. In fact, I saw this film several times as a child and my nieces also watched this film when they were children. They are now 21 and 20.
While this novel and film can be understood as being a simple children’s story, there is also another dimension to the novel which is actually a social commentary of the time in the US. The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is one of America's favorite pieces of juvenile literature. Children like it because it is a good story, full of fun characters and exciting adventures. Adults--especially those of us in history and related fields--like it because we can read between L. Frank Baum's lines and see various images of the United States at the turn of the century. That has been true since 1964, when American Quarterly published Henry M. Littlefield's "The Wizard of Oz: Parable on Populism." Littlefield described all sorts of hidden meanings and allusions to Gilded Age society in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz: the wicked Witch of the East represented eastern industrialists and bankers who controlled the people (the Munchkins); the Scarecrow was the wise but naive western farmer; the Tin Woodman stood for the dehumanized industrial worker; the Cowardly Lion was William Jennings Bryan, Populist presidential candidate in 1896; the Yellow Brick Road, with all its dangers, was the gold standard; Dorothy's silver slippers (in the film they were ruby red, but Baum originally made them silver) represented the Populists' solution to the nation's economic woes ("the free and unlimited coinage of silver"); Emerald City was Washington, D.C.; the Wizard, "a little bumbling old man, hiding behind a facade of Paper Mache and noise, . . . able to be everything to everybody," was any of the Gilded Age presidents.2
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz was no longer an innocent fairy tale. According to Littlefield, Baum, a reform-minded Democrat who supported William Jennings Bryan's pro-silver candidacy, wrote the book as a parable of the Populists, an allegory of their failed efforts to reform the nation in 1896. "Baum never allowed the consistency of the allegory to take precedence over the theme of youthful entertainment," Littlefield hedged at one point; "the allegory always remains in a minor key." Still, he concluded that "the relationships and analogies outlined above . . . are far too consistent to be coincidental."3
It was an interesting notion, one which scholars could not leave alone, and they soon began to find additional correspondences between Populism and The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Richard Jensen, in a 1971 study of Midwestern politics and culture, devoted two pages to Baum's story. He implicitly qualified Littlefield by pointing out that not all pro-Bryan silverites were Populists. But Jensen then proceeded to add two new points to the standard Littlefield interpretation, finding analogies for Toto and Oz itself: Dorothy's faithful dog represented the tee totaling Prohibitionists, an important part of the silverite coalition, and anyone familiar with the silverites' slogan "16 to 1"--that is, the ratio of sixteen ounces of silver to one ounce of gold--would have instantly recognized "Oz" as the abbreviation for "ounce."4
A few years later, literary scholar Brian Attebery wrote that "it is too much to say . . . that The Wizard is a 'Parable on Populism,' but it does share many of the Populist concerns and biases." Like Jensen, Attebery cautioned against an uncritical acceptance of Littlefield; and again like Jensen, he went on to suggest an analogy of his own: "Dorothy, bold, resourceful, leading the men around her toward success, is a juvenile Mary Lease, the Kansas firebrand who told her neighbors to raise less corn and more hell."5
The most extensive treatment of the Littlefield thesis is an article by Hugh Rockoff in the Journal of Political Economy. Rockoff, who saw in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz "a sophisticated commentary on the political and economic debates of the Populist Era," discovered a surprising number of new analogies. The Deadly Poppy Field, where the Cowardly Lion fell asleep and could not move forward, was the anti-imperialism that threatened to make Bryan forget the main issue of silver (note the Oriental connotation of poppies and opium). Once in the Emerald Palace, Dorothy had to pass through seven halls and climb three flights of stairs; seven and three make seventy-three, which stands for the Crime of '73, the congressional act that eliminated the coinage of silver and that proved to all Populists the collusion between congress and bankers. The Wicked Witch of the East was Grover Cleveland; of the West, William McKinley. The enslavement of the yellow Winkies was "a not very well disguised reference to McKinley's decision to deny immediate independence to the Philippines" after the Spanish-American War. The Wizard himself was Mark Hanna, McKinley's campaign manager, although Rockoff noted that "this is one of the few points at which the allegory does not work straightforwardly." About half of Rockoff's article consisted of an economic analysis that justified Bryan and Baum's silver stance.5
While most people in the US would never consider that a children’s novel would have a secondary theme dealing with political issues, this idea is not limited to The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Gulliver’s Travels by Jonathan Swift (1667- 1745) was also believed to have secondary theme based upon social concerns.
Jonathan Swift's ultimate satirical masterpiece, Gulliver's Travels, scrutinizes human nature through a misanthropic eye. More directly, it examines the bastardization English society underwent. The brilliant tale depicts the journey of Lemuel Gulliver, an Englishman, and his distorted encounters. Examining the prominent political and social conflicts of England in the eighteenth century, Swift's critical work causes much controversy. Gulliver's travels leads him to places of opposite environments and presents him with different opportunities. Through Gulliver's journey, Swift ridicules Gulliver as an individual character, and also as a product of England's social practices.
First, Gulliver travels to Lilliput, a land of miniature humans. The culture and society of the Lilliputians is very similar to that of Gulliver's home, England. However, in this undersized environment, Gulliver's outlook is altered.6
This secondary theme is also present in Russian literature. There are some scholars of classic Russian literature who are convinced that Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov (1891-1940) was not only about the relationship between the Master and Margarita, but was also a social commentary about Soviet politics during the time that Joseph Stalin (1878-1953) was the Soviet premier. In my article “Absurdity of Reality”7 I mention that some scholars believe that Woland, the devil in Master and Margarita, was actually a representation of Stalin. The fact that Bulgakov was unable to leave the Soviet Union by order of Joseph Stalin, even though he was very ill, seems to confirm that there is a connection between Stalin and this masterpiece. Bulgakov died at the age of fifty-one, but he could have possibly lived quite a bit longer if he had been able to go to Paris where the rest of his family (except for his third wife who remained with her husband). The medicine that Bulgakov needed was not available in the Soviet Union.
End Notes
As a children’s story, the premise is very simple. Kansas farm girl Dorothy Gale lives with her Aunt Em, Uncle Henry, and three farm hands, Hickory, Hunk, and Zeke. When Miss Almira Gulch is bitten by Dorothy's pet Cairn Terrier, Toto, she gets a sheriff's order and takes him away to be destroyed. He escapes and returns to Dorothy, who, fearing for his life, runs away with him.
Dorothy soon encounters a traveling fortune teller named Professor Marvel, who guesses she has run away and tells her fortune. He convinces her to return home by falsely telling her that Aunt Em has fallen ill from grief. With a tornado fast approaching, she rushes back to the farmhouse, but is unable to join her family in the locked storm cellar. Taking shelter inside the house, she is knocked unconscious by a window frame blown in by the twister.
Dorothy awakens to find the house being carried away by the tornado. After it falls back to earth, she opens the door and finds herself alone in a strange village. Arriving in a floating bubble, Glinda, the Good Witch of the North, informs her that her house landed on and killed the Wicked Witch of the East.
The timid Munchkins come out of hiding to celebrate the Witch's demise by singing "Ding-Dong! The Witch Is Dead". Their celebration is interrupted when the Wicked Witch of the West (Miss Gulch) suddenly appears in a cloud of smoke and tries to claim her dead sister's powerful ruby slippers. However, Glinda magically transfers them onto Dorothy's feet and reminds the Witch of the West that her power does not work in Munchkinland. She promises Dorothy "I'll get you, my pretty...and your little dog, too!" before leaving the same way she arrived. When Dorothy asks how to get back home, Glinda advises her to seek the help of the mysterious Wizard of Oz in the Emerald City, which she can reach by following the Yellow Brick Road, and warns her never to remove the ruby slippers or she will be at the mercy of the Wicked Witch.
On her way to the city, Dorothy meets a Scarecrow (Hickory), a Tin Man (Hunk), and a Cowardly Lion (Zeke), who lament to her that they respectively lack a brain, a heart, and courage. The three decide to accompany her in hopes that the Wizard will also fulfill their desires, although they demonstrate that they already have the qualities they believe they lack: the Scarecrow has several good ideas, the Tin Man is kind and sympathetic, and the Lion, though terrified, is ready to face danger.
After Dorothy and the Cowardly Lion nearly succumb to one of the Witch's traps, the quartet enters the Emerald City and is allowed to see the Wizard, who appears amidst smoke and flames as a disembodied, intimidating head. In a booming voice, he states that he will consider granting their wishes if they bring him the Wicked Witch's broomstick.
They set out for the Witch's castle, but she detects them and dispatches her army of flying monkeys, who carry Dorothy and Toto back to her. When the Witch threatens to drown Toto, Dorothy agrees to give up the ruby slippers, but a shower of sparks prevents their removal. Realizing they can't be removed unless Dorothy dies, the Witch leaves to ponder how to accomplish this.
Toto escapes and leads Dorothy's companions to the castle. After overpowering some of the Winkie guards and disguising themselves in their uniforms, they find and free her. The Witch and the Winkies corner the group on a parapet, where she sets the Scarecrow's arm ablaze with her broomstick. Dorothy throws water on her friend and accidentally splashes the Witch, causing her to melt. The Winkies are delighted, and their captain gives Dorothy the broomstick.
Upon their triumphant return to the Wizard's chamber, Toto opens a curtain, revealing him to be an ordinary man (Professor Marvel) operating a console of wheels and levers while speaking into a microphone. Apologetic, he explains that Dorothy's companions already possess what they have been seeking all along, but bestows upon them tokens of esteem in recognition of their respective virtues. Explaining that he too was born in Kansas, and was brought to Oz by a runaway hot air balloon, he offers to take Dorothy home in the same balloon, leaving the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Lion in charge of the Emerald City.
As they are about to leave, Toto jumps out of the balloon's basket and Dorothy runs after him. The Wizard, unable to control the balloon, leaves without her. As she despairs of ever getting back home, Glinda appears and tells her that she always had the power to return home, but that she needed to learn for herself that she didn't have to run away to find her heart's desire. She bids her friends goodbye, then follows Glinda's instructions to close her eyes, tap her heels together three times, and keep repeating "There's no place like home".
Dorothy awakens in her bedroom in Kansas, surrounded by family and friends, and tells them of her journey. Although Auntie Em assures her it was all a dream, Dorothy insists it was real, especially since she saw all the people she knows in the Land of Oz, and promises never to run away from home again.1
There are some differences between this film and the original novel. For example, in the novel, Dorothy’s slippers were silver, not ruby. Also, Glinda, the good witch, was actually a collection of three characters in the novel. This film appears on US television annually and has been popular with numerous generations. In fact, I saw this film several times as a child and my nieces also watched this film when they were children. They are now 21 and 20.
While this novel and film can be understood as being a simple children’s story, there is also another dimension to the novel which is actually a social commentary of the time in the US. The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is one of America's favorite pieces of juvenile literature. Children like it because it is a good story, full of fun characters and exciting adventures. Adults--especially those of us in history and related fields--like it because we can read between L. Frank Baum's lines and see various images of the United States at the turn of the century. That has been true since 1964, when American Quarterly published Henry M. Littlefield's "The Wizard of Oz: Parable on Populism." Littlefield described all sorts of hidden meanings and allusions to Gilded Age society in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz: the wicked Witch of the East represented eastern industrialists and bankers who controlled the people (the Munchkins); the Scarecrow was the wise but naive western farmer; the Tin Woodman stood for the dehumanized industrial worker; the Cowardly Lion was William Jennings Bryan, Populist presidential candidate in 1896; the Yellow Brick Road, with all its dangers, was the gold standard; Dorothy's silver slippers (in the film they were ruby red, but Baum originally made them silver) represented the Populists' solution to the nation's economic woes ("the free and unlimited coinage of silver"); Emerald City was Washington, D.C.; the Wizard, "a little bumbling old man, hiding behind a facade of Paper Mache and noise, . . . able to be everything to everybody," was any of the Gilded Age presidents.2
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz was no longer an innocent fairy tale. According to Littlefield, Baum, a reform-minded Democrat who supported William Jennings Bryan's pro-silver candidacy, wrote the book as a parable of the Populists, an allegory of their failed efforts to reform the nation in 1896. "Baum never allowed the consistency of the allegory to take precedence over the theme of youthful entertainment," Littlefield hedged at one point; "the allegory always remains in a minor key." Still, he concluded that "the relationships and analogies outlined above . . . are far too consistent to be coincidental."3
It was an interesting notion, one which scholars could not leave alone, and they soon began to find additional correspondences between Populism and The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Richard Jensen, in a 1971 study of Midwestern politics and culture, devoted two pages to Baum's story. He implicitly qualified Littlefield by pointing out that not all pro-Bryan silverites were Populists. But Jensen then proceeded to add two new points to the standard Littlefield interpretation, finding analogies for Toto and Oz itself: Dorothy's faithful dog represented the tee totaling Prohibitionists, an important part of the silverite coalition, and anyone familiar with the silverites' slogan "16 to 1"--that is, the ratio of sixteen ounces of silver to one ounce of gold--would have instantly recognized "Oz" as the abbreviation for "ounce."4
A few years later, literary scholar Brian Attebery wrote that "it is too much to say . . . that The Wizard is a 'Parable on Populism,' but it does share many of the Populist concerns and biases." Like Jensen, Attebery cautioned against an uncritical acceptance of Littlefield; and again like Jensen, he went on to suggest an analogy of his own: "Dorothy, bold, resourceful, leading the men around her toward success, is a juvenile Mary Lease, the Kansas firebrand who told her neighbors to raise less corn and more hell."5
The most extensive treatment of the Littlefield thesis is an article by Hugh Rockoff in the Journal of Political Economy. Rockoff, who saw in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz "a sophisticated commentary on the political and economic debates of the Populist Era," discovered a surprising number of new analogies. The Deadly Poppy Field, where the Cowardly Lion fell asleep and could not move forward, was the anti-imperialism that threatened to make Bryan forget the main issue of silver (note the Oriental connotation of poppies and opium). Once in the Emerald Palace, Dorothy had to pass through seven halls and climb three flights of stairs; seven and three make seventy-three, which stands for the Crime of '73, the congressional act that eliminated the coinage of silver and that proved to all Populists the collusion between congress and bankers. The Wicked Witch of the East was Grover Cleveland; of the West, William McKinley. The enslavement of the yellow Winkies was "a not very well disguised reference to McKinley's decision to deny immediate independence to the Philippines" after the Spanish-American War. The Wizard himself was Mark Hanna, McKinley's campaign manager, although Rockoff noted that "this is one of the few points at which the allegory does not work straightforwardly." About half of Rockoff's article consisted of an economic analysis that justified Bryan and Baum's silver stance.5
While most people in the US would never consider that a children’s novel would have a secondary theme dealing with political issues, this idea is not limited to The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Gulliver’s Travels by Jonathan Swift (1667- 1745) was also believed to have secondary theme based upon social concerns.
Jonathan Swift's ultimate satirical masterpiece, Gulliver's Travels, scrutinizes human nature through a misanthropic eye. More directly, it examines the bastardization English society underwent. The brilliant tale depicts the journey of Lemuel Gulliver, an Englishman, and his distorted encounters. Examining the prominent political and social conflicts of England in the eighteenth century, Swift's critical work causes much controversy. Gulliver's travels leads him to places of opposite environments and presents him with different opportunities. Through Gulliver's journey, Swift ridicules Gulliver as an individual character, and also as a product of England's social practices.
First, Gulliver travels to Lilliput, a land of miniature humans. The culture and society of the Lilliputians is very similar to that of Gulliver's home, England. However, in this undersized environment, Gulliver's outlook is altered.6
This secondary theme is also present in Russian literature. There are some scholars of classic Russian literature who are convinced that Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov (1891-1940) was not only about the relationship between the Master and Margarita, but was also a social commentary about Soviet politics during the time that Joseph Stalin (1878-1953) was the Soviet premier. In my article “Absurdity of Reality”7 I mention that some scholars believe that Woland, the devil in Master and Margarita, was actually a representation of Stalin. The fact that Bulgakov was unable to leave the Soviet Union by order of Joseph Stalin, even though he was very ill, seems to confirm that there is a connection between Stalin and this masterpiece. Bulgakov died at the age of fifty-one, but he could have possibly lived quite a bit longer if he had been able to go to Paris where the rest of his family (except for his third wife who remained with her husband). The medicine that Bulgakov needed was not available in the Soviet Union.
Whether or not
you accept the fact that these novels have a secondary theme, it is an
interesting idea to ponder. This will
allow the author to express his opinion regarding very important issues while,
at the same time, entertaining his readers with an intriguing or entertaining
story. If you have never read these
novels, I recommend that you do so. If
you have read them, this will give you a reason to re-read them and examine
them as social commentaries.
End Notes
1)
“The
Wizard of Oz (1939 film)” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wizard_of_Oz_(1939_film)
(accessed 5/12/12)
2)
Henry
M. Littlefield "The Wizard of Oz: Parable on Populism," American Quarterly 16 (1964): 47-58
(quotation on 54); L. Frank Baum, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (Chicago,
1900).
3)
Littlefield,
"Parable on Populism," 50, 58.
4)
Richard
Jensen The Winning of the Midwest: Social and Political Conflict, 1888-1896
(Chicago, 1971), 282-83.
5)
Brian
Attebery The Fantasy Tradition in American Literature: From Irving to Le
Guin (Bloomington, 1980), 86-87.
6)
“Gulliver’s
Travels: An Altered Perspective” http://www.123helpme.com/gullivers-travels-an-altered-perspective-preview.asp?id=168678
(accessed 5/12/12)
7)
“Absurdity
of Reality” http://heideggerm1.blogspot.com/2011/06/absurdity-of-reality.html
(accessed 5/12/12)
Thursday, May 10, 2012
КРАСОТА РУССКОЙ ДУШИ
Для описания ментальности русского человека, выделения особенностей его духовного развития, в литературе не раз использовалось понятие «Русская душа». О русской душе пишет и Н. Гоголь, и Л. Толстой, и Ф. Достоевский.
Термин «Русская душа» расскрывается через культурные тенденции русских, их восприятие жизни, отношения к религиозной и философской сфере бытия. Это говорит о том, что в Росии внутренняя сущность человека, основы его мировоззрения служат ключом к пониманию его личности. Проявление русской души видится через эмоциональную сферу жизни, а не через деятельностную. Поэтому для описания русской души используются такие характеристики, как глубина, сила и сострадание. По словам Достоевского, «самая основная, самая элементарная духовная потребность русского народа - есть потребность страдания, вездесущая и неугасимая, везде и во всем» [1].
Идеи Достоевского о русской душе тесно связаны с православием, в котором идеал Христа отражается через сострадание другим, через готовность умереть за других, через спокойное смирение, принятие этого.
Абстрактного «страдания» (страдания ради страдания) для россиянина не существует. Страдание ради страданий не имеет никакого смысла в русской культуре. Народной ментальности чужды депрессии и получение удовольствий от унижения и бесплодного страдания. В русском народе как пружина сжата внутренняя сила. Именно она позволила выжить русскому народу в самые трагические дни истории. Не будь этой пружины, не выжил бы русский народ в самые трагические дни своей истории, а был бы сметен, погиб без остатка, как многие другие народы земли.
Народный гнев страшен. Но он никогда не принимает националистическую окраску. Идеал русского человека предписывает делиться последним, не оставлять чувства юмора в самые тяжелые минуты (народная музыка, как ничто другое, отражает эту сторону русской души (частушка).
Русская душа характеризуется в литературе как: чувствительная, творческая, сострадательная, терпеливая, сильная (благодаря именно ее силе, русский человек можетвыжить в невыносимых условиях), поэтическая, мистическая, фаталистическая, интроспективная. По литературным произведениям можно судить о том, что русский не доверяет рациональной мысли, полагаясь на интуицию, быстро увлекается, проявляя способность чувствовать широкий спектр крайних человеческих эмоций (от абсолютной радости и умиротворения до глубокого отчаяния) и т.д., и т.д., и т.д. (список можно продолжить). Русские смогли сохранить свою мировоззренческую целостность, пройдя нелегкий исторический путь. Именно у русских в культуре заложен идеал абсолютной честности через приверженность к вере, И это несмотря на то, что реалии действительности давно должны были уничтожить его.
Так и понятие красоты в русской ментальности, в первую очередь, соотносится с понятием внутреннего богатсва человека, его духовной целостности. При этом понимание внутренней красоты не носит жертвенный характер. Такое выражение, как «красота требует жертв» заимствованное из западной культуры, никогда не понималось русскими женщинами буквально. Это скорее для них шутка, чем руководство к действию.
Не существует понятия «немецкая душа», «английская» или «американская». Именно в характеристике ментальности русских закрепилось слово «душа». Концепция русской души возникла в 1840-е годы прежде всего как литературное явление. Известный российский писатель Николай Гоголь и литературный критик Виссарион Белинский (1811-1848) совместно ввели данный термин в 1842 году в опубликованном шедевре Гоголя Мертвые души. Русские помещики при переписи считали своих крепостных для целей бухгалтерского учета, по «душам». С одной стороны, название романа отражает аферу главного героя, построенную на приобретении бухгалтерских документов, в которых числятся умершие крепостные крестьяне. Однако, помимо этого буквального смысла, Гоголь говорит о потере человеческих душ у живых людей.
Виссарион Белинский, известный радикальный критик, продолжил идею Гоголя дальше, и вывел из романа характеристики русской ментальности, так называемой «национальной души», существующей у народа. В самом деле, в своем анализе творчества Гоголя, Белинский использовал термин "русская душа" несколько раз, и именно от него данное выражение стало крылатым, получив со временем более четкое определение через труды такого автора, как Ф. М. Достоевский.
Понятие «русской души», сформировавшись как надклассовое, включающее особенности национального характера, помогло определить национальную идентичность [3]. Суждение о «Русской душе» эволюционировало и стало известно в западной культуре в последующие десятилетия, благодаря работам Ф. М. Достоевского. В своих произведениях Достоевский расскрывает весь психологизм своих героев, говорит о «народном духе». Вместе с тем, в его произведениях множество «невысказанных, бессознательных идей», которые постоянно и сильно ощущаются. В 1881 году к моменту смерти Достоевского, «русская душа» завершила свою эволюцию в Russia [3].
Начиная примерно с 1880 по 1930 годы, опять же во многом благодаря Достоевскому, с представлением о «русской душе» познакомились за рубежом. С тех пор данное словосочетание носит не только сугубо понятийное значение, но и служит брендом при восприятии не только единичного русского человека среди иностранцев, но и всего народа.
Для многих европейцев этот термин стал позитивной альтернативой восприятию русских как отстающего от западной культуры народа. Русский народ предстал через раскрытие понятия «русская душа» с той невинностью и душевной чистотой, которую давно потерял циничный Запад. Популярность "русской души" росла и в двадцатом веке.
Казалось, в 1930-е годы данная концепция ушла в небытие, но на самом деле она продолжала жить в произведениях многочисленных писателей, которые продолжали ее разрабатывать [3]. Казалось, что концепция «русской души» вышла из моды, ее место стал занимать пропагандируемый бренд «Советского человека». Теперь, когда Советский Союз ушел в прошлое, актуальность понимания русского человека через концепцию «русской души» возросла. В России дух православной духовности, даже среди тех, кто не считает себя православным, стал определяющим. Более того, он стал частью повседневной жизни русского, украинского и белорусского народов.
Множество испытаний выдержало население в бывших советских республиках с крахом Советского Союза. Ситуация по-своему была сложной в каждой из этих стран. Надежда была только на время. Анализируя сейчас то, что помогло людям не только выжить, но и не потерять свое достоинство в эпоху хаоса и становления новой государственности, мы опять приходим к концепции «русской души», определяя ее как источник внутренней силы и устойчивости. Обращение к концепции «русской души» как к идеалу позволяет справиться русскому человеку с множеством невзгод и исторических драм. Существование российского человека опрделяется через наличие внутреннего богатства, души. Уничтожишь душу – уничтожишь и русскую ментальность.
Душа в России относится к женскому роду. Характеризуя восприятие красоты и доброты в современной России, через анализ «русской души» приходим к выводу, что их понимание возможно только по отношению к современной русской женщине. Доброта, искренняя деликатность русских женщин, готовность понять других людей во многом определяются жизнью русского народа. До сих пор многие иностранцы считают Михаила Зощенко (1895-1958), который описал жизнь россиян в 1920-х и 30-х годов, писателем-фантастом. Между тем, коммунальные квартиры, где несколько семей живут на небольшой площади, разделенной на крошечные комнаты, с одним туалетом и ванной для всех не является такой редкостью, даже сейчас. Не у каждого есть отдельная квартира. Согласно западным параметрам эти квартиры считаются малыми даже для одного человека. Российские семьи из 4-5 человек живут в скромной двухкомнатной квартире площадью 58 квадратных метров. Очень часто несколько поколений живут в одной малогабаритной квартире. В России поговорка «в тесноте, но не в обиде» пользуется популярностью. Кажется, что здесь условия проживания вызывают чувство особого единства, когда необходимо считаться все время с другими, принимать других такими, как они. Россияне привыкли к тесной связи с другими людьми. Русский человек воспитывается в условиях зависимости от потребностей других людей. Русские обладают уникальной способностью адаптации, особенно там, где это касается женщин. Эти условия, казалось бы, невыносимые для иностранцев, воспринимаются русским народом как должные. По этой причине русские жены очень терпеливы и всегда готовы идти на компромисс в их семейной жизни. Ситуации, которые будут рассматриваться западной женщиной как нарушение ее интересов, могут быть проигнорированы русской. Русская жена всегда готова к компромиссу. Это искренняя мобильность и терпение свойственное россиянам, часто не хватало на Западе [4].
Влияние, которое оказали на русскую культуру такие писатели, как Федор Достоевский, Николай Гоголь, Лев Толстой и другие было глубоким. Они, конечно, дети своего времени, но, независимо от этого, они повлияли и продолжают влиять на мировоззрение множества поколений, которые пришли после них. И до тех пор, пока они влияют на становление русского человека, концепция «русской души» не исчезнет.
Русская женщина является не только олицетворением «русской души», но и обеспечивает условия, в которых красота этой души может быть выражена. Уют и теплая атмосфера дома дело чести российской домохозяйки. Она считает свой дом продолжением себя, как символ счастливой семейной жизни. В России до сих пор дом убирают сами, без специально нанятых для этого домработниц. Большинство русских женщин заняты в уборке квартиры и приготовлении пищи. Они часто сами шьют, вяжут, ремонтируют вещи. Росская красавица, способная улучшить жилье с помощью кисти или шпателя живописью – для запада является чудом. Русская женщина всегда старается сделать свой дом светом, чистым и радостным. Посещение ресторанов и кафе в России считается общественным мероприятием. Рядовые граждане не ходят в рестораны «просто поесть». Большинство русских семей едят дома. Это объясняется не только материальными причинами и привычками россиян, к вкусной домашней еде, это еще и отношение к таинству семьи и ее целостности[5]. Понятие о красоте русской души является не просто продуктом конце девятнадцатого века, но живет и процветает сегодня через повседневную жизнь русской женщины. Сейчас, возможно, иначе, чем во времена Льва Толстого, но она жива! Каждое последующее поколение будет иметь свое собственное проявление этой реальности, однако, красота русской души никогда не умрет.
Библиографический список
1) Ries, Nancy Russian Talk: Culture and Conversation During Perestroika (NY: Cornell University Press, 1997)
2) “Russian Soul” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_soul
3) Robert C. Williams, "The Russian Soul: A Study in European Thought and Non-European Nationalism" Journal of the History of Ideas 31 (1970): 573-588, accessed October 27, 2011.
4) “About Russian Women” http://www.single-russian-woman.com/russianwomen.php (accessed 11/7/11)
5) “About Russian Women”
Impact of Incarceration on Genius
Between 1850 and 1854, Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky (1821-1881) spent four long, punishing years in a Siberian prison-stockade. During this time he lived cheek-by-jowl with a motley collection of prisoners from the Russian peasantry, a few convicts from among the Russian educated class or “gentry”, and one other member of the Petrashevsky group of liberals and radicals. These prison-years in Siberia, as Dostoevsky himself stressed later, were of decisive importance in his life and resulted in what he called the “transformation of his conviction”.1 The experience garnered in these years changed Dostoevsky from an opponent to a supporter of Czarism, and finally consolidated his faith in Christ and in the Christian God who transcended the bounds of reason. A clear understanding of what happened to Dostoevsky during these crucial years would, accordingly, would go a long way to explain many of the baffling and still enigmatic features of the creative universe of his great novels.2
This novel was published in 1860 during a brief thaw in the strict censorship of the time. The House of the Dead at first positions itself as a novel, with an elaborate editorial framing device designed to mollify the censor and other critics. The work is presented as a manuscript left among the papers of a former prisoner. Behind the ‘I’ of Alexander Petrovich Goryanchikov, imprisoned for 10 years for murdering his wife, (he serves as a narrator in the novel) hides the ‘I’ of Dostoevsky, imprisoned for 4 years for a political crime. This initial narrative masking creates up a certain freedom, allowing Dostoevsky to describe objectively and in detail the life of the prison without making it appear as a political act, or an overt attack on the system itself. The novelistic mask soon slips; however, as it emerges that, unlike a novel, there is no plot, no ‘setting’ and no ‘characters’.
The autobiographical and documentary now come to the fore. The writing is characterized by a clinical objectivity. Phrases such as, It is a fact that…. abound. We are given detailed descriptions of the social structure of the prison, the economics of the prison, the squalid living conditions, the daily routine, the excessive brutality of the punishments, the grueling labor, utterly relentless and crushing boredom, and the lice-ridden latrine-stinking overcrowding. Like modern oral historiography, we are given some of the convict’s stories, from their own mouths, with little or no ‘authorial’ interference or comment. The emphasis is on facts. The (melo)drama and theatricality of Dostoevsky’s previous work is entirely absent, even in the stories told by the convicts of their crimes, and in the descriptions of the punishments meted out to them for infractions of prison regulations, and the outbreaks of sudden violence that characterize prison life. Everything is understated and downplayed, and left to speak for itself. There is none of the angry hectoring of Charles Dickens (1812-1870), for example, or the biting sarcasm of Victor Hugo (1802-1885), those other great reforming zealots of the 19th century who were such huge influences on early Dostoevsky.
At the same time, the book addresses a number of philosophical problems:
1. The inequality of punishment for the same crime
2. The gap between appearance and reality and how to interpret reality
3. The effect on the character of judicial brutality, both on those who administer it, and those who suffer under it
4. The nature of freedom
5. The nature of philanthropy
6. The importance of hope
These themes run like threads throughout the narrative but appear with more frequency and intensity towards the end of the second half, where we can understand them more because we have, like the narrator, spent more time in the prison, and are able to understand it better.3
This novel mirrors several of the horrifying experiences he witnessed while in prison. He recalls the guards’ brutality and relish in performing unspeakably cruel acts, the crimes that the convicted criminals committed, and the fact that tousled amongst these great brutes were good and decent individuals.4 However, he also displays admiration for the convicts’ abilities to commit murders without the slightest change in conscience. It was a stark contrast of him and his high sensitivity levels. It was during his time in prison that he first began experiencing his epileptic seizures. House of the Dead led Dostoevsky to include the theme of murder in his later works, a theme not found in any of his works preceding House of the Dead.5
The theme of murder was prevalent in The Idiot, Brothers Karamazov, and Crime and Punishment. It seems rather obvious that his time in prison had a major influence on these three masterpieces. In fact, in Brothers Karamazov, the reader is able to enter into the life of Karamazov family and experience the dynamics of this family; however, this novel is largely a murder mystery. In The Idiot, Parfyon Semyonovich Rogozhin ends up killing the woman he claimed that he loved. The main event in Crime and Punishment is the murder of a pawnbroker by Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov. The rest of the novel shows his descent into madness.
To his contemporary readers, Dostoyevsky appeared as a writer primarily interested in the terrible aspects of human existence. However, later critics have recognized that the novelist sought to plumb the depths of the psyche, in order to reveal the full range of the human experience, from the basest desires to the most elevated spiritual yearnings. Above all, he illustrated the universal human struggle to understand God and self. Dostoyevsky was, Katherine Mansfield wrote, “a being who loved, in spite of everything, adored life, even while he knew the dank, dark places.”6
Not every person who has been incarcerated became known as geniuses, but this is certainly true in Dostoevsky’s case. He was a member of the intellectual community in St. Petersburg prior to his imprisonment and went on to become known as one of the greatest Russian authors of all time.
End Notes
1) The Russian word originally translated as “transformation” is pererozhdenie which carries the religious implication of rebirth or regeneration.
2) Dostoevsky: The House of the Dead by Joseph Frank in The Swanee Review, Vol. 2, 1966, p. 25.
3) “Notes from House of the Dead by Dostoevsky” http://thelectern.blogspot.com/2009/02/impression-made-by-reality-is-always.html
4) "Fyodor Dostoyevsky." Encyclopedia Britannica Online, 2011. http://www.britannica.com/ (accessed 5/9/12)
5) Dostoevsky, Fyodor Memoirs from House of the Dead (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1956), p. xii. First English translation in 1956.
6) “Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky (1821-1881)” http://people.brandeis.edu/~teuber/dostoevskybio.html#_thehouseofthedead (accessed 5/10/12)
This novel was published in 1860 during a brief thaw in the strict censorship of the time. The House of the Dead at first positions itself as a novel, with an elaborate editorial framing device designed to mollify the censor and other critics. The work is presented as a manuscript left among the papers of a former prisoner. Behind the ‘I’ of Alexander Petrovich Goryanchikov, imprisoned for 10 years for murdering his wife, (he serves as a narrator in the novel) hides the ‘I’ of Dostoevsky, imprisoned for 4 years for a political crime. This initial narrative masking creates up a certain freedom, allowing Dostoevsky to describe objectively and in detail the life of the prison without making it appear as a political act, or an overt attack on the system itself. The novelistic mask soon slips; however, as it emerges that, unlike a novel, there is no plot, no ‘setting’ and no ‘characters’.
The autobiographical and documentary now come to the fore. The writing is characterized by a clinical objectivity. Phrases such as, It is a fact that…. abound. We are given detailed descriptions of the social structure of the prison, the economics of the prison, the squalid living conditions, the daily routine, the excessive brutality of the punishments, the grueling labor, utterly relentless and crushing boredom, and the lice-ridden latrine-stinking overcrowding. Like modern oral historiography, we are given some of the convict’s stories, from their own mouths, with little or no ‘authorial’ interference or comment. The emphasis is on facts. The (melo)drama and theatricality of Dostoevsky’s previous work is entirely absent, even in the stories told by the convicts of their crimes, and in the descriptions of the punishments meted out to them for infractions of prison regulations, and the outbreaks of sudden violence that characterize prison life. Everything is understated and downplayed, and left to speak for itself. There is none of the angry hectoring of Charles Dickens (1812-1870), for example, or the biting sarcasm of Victor Hugo (1802-1885), those other great reforming zealots of the 19th century who were such huge influences on early Dostoevsky.
At the same time, the book addresses a number of philosophical problems:
1. The inequality of punishment for the same crime
2. The gap between appearance and reality and how to interpret reality
3. The effect on the character of judicial brutality, both on those who administer it, and those who suffer under it
4. The nature of freedom
5. The nature of philanthropy
6. The importance of hope
These themes run like threads throughout the narrative but appear with more frequency and intensity towards the end of the second half, where we can understand them more because we have, like the narrator, spent more time in the prison, and are able to understand it better.3
This novel mirrors several of the horrifying experiences he witnessed while in prison. He recalls the guards’ brutality and relish in performing unspeakably cruel acts, the crimes that the convicted criminals committed, and the fact that tousled amongst these great brutes were good and decent individuals.4 However, he also displays admiration for the convicts’ abilities to commit murders without the slightest change in conscience. It was a stark contrast of him and his high sensitivity levels. It was during his time in prison that he first began experiencing his epileptic seizures. House of the Dead led Dostoevsky to include the theme of murder in his later works, a theme not found in any of his works preceding House of the Dead.5
The theme of murder was prevalent in The Idiot, Brothers Karamazov, and Crime and Punishment. It seems rather obvious that his time in prison had a major influence on these three masterpieces. In fact, in Brothers Karamazov, the reader is able to enter into the life of Karamazov family and experience the dynamics of this family; however, this novel is largely a murder mystery. In The Idiot, Parfyon Semyonovich Rogozhin ends up killing the woman he claimed that he loved. The main event in Crime and Punishment is the murder of a pawnbroker by Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov. The rest of the novel shows his descent into madness.
To his contemporary readers, Dostoyevsky appeared as a writer primarily interested in the terrible aspects of human existence. However, later critics have recognized that the novelist sought to plumb the depths of the psyche, in order to reveal the full range of the human experience, from the basest desires to the most elevated spiritual yearnings. Above all, he illustrated the universal human struggle to understand God and self. Dostoyevsky was, Katherine Mansfield wrote, “a being who loved, in spite of everything, adored life, even while he knew the dank, dark places.”6
Not every person who has been incarcerated became known as geniuses, but this is certainly true in Dostoevsky’s case. He was a member of the intellectual community in St. Petersburg prior to his imprisonment and went on to become known as one of the greatest Russian authors of all time.
End Notes
1) The Russian word originally translated as “transformation” is pererozhdenie which carries the religious implication of rebirth or regeneration.
2) Dostoevsky: The House of the Dead by Joseph Frank in The Swanee Review, Vol. 2, 1966, p. 25.
3) “Notes from House of the Dead by Dostoevsky” http://thelectern.blogspot.com/2009/02/impression-made-by-reality-is-always.html
4) "Fyodor Dostoyevsky." Encyclopedia Britannica Online, 2011. http://www.britannica.com/ (accessed 5/9/12)
5) Dostoevsky, Fyodor Memoirs from House of the Dead (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1956), p. xii. First English translation in 1956.
6) “Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky (1821-1881)” http://people.brandeis.edu/~teuber/dostoevskybio.html#_thehouseofthedead (accessed 5/10/12)
Tuesday, May 8, 2012
Inspiring Creativity
In my article “Being Alone with One’s Thoughts” 1 I discussed the issue of being alone versus being lonely. The need for constantly stimulation is very prevalent in Western society, but was not always found in other cultures around the world. For example, Russian society has always had a more reflexive mindset. This may be changing now that Western culture has made its way into Russia and that part of the world. Hopefully, it will continue to endure into the next generation.
In an interview, Russian film director Andrei Tarkovsky [Андрей Арсеньевич Тарковский] (1932-1986) was asked what message he would like to leave for young people. Tarkovsky said that they should learn to love solitude and to be able to be alone with themselves. He believed that young people were carrying out noisy and aggressive actions in an effort not to be alone. He felt that all individuals must learn to be on his own as a child. This is not the same as being alone. He is referring to the idea of not becoming bored with oneself, which is sees as a very dangerous symptom, almost a disease.2
One thing which being alone can inspire, regardless of whether this isolation is voluntary or forced, is a sense of creativity. There are numerous examples of highly creative people who chose to be alone for extended periods of time and others who were forced into solitude as a result of imprisonment.
On Christmas Day 1849, Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky (1821-1881) began the long journey from St. Petersburg to Siberia where he was to spend the next four years in a prison camp. Together with other members of the Petrashevsky circle, a group of intellectuals, he had been arrested in April 1849, and had already spent eight months as a prisoner in the Peter and Paul fortress. During this initial period, he was in solitary confinement, and, at first, was not allowed books or writing materials. In spite of this, he discovered that he had inner resources which enabled him to tolerate captivity far better than he had initially expected. His arrest may even have saved him from a breakdown, rather than precipitating it; for there is evidence that his participation in an underground revolutionary organization had been preying on his mind during the previous winter, and had brought him to the edge of a collapse.
When, at the beginning of July, the prisoners were allowed to receive books from the fortress library Dostoevsky fell upon them. He also wrote to his brother, Mikhail, telling him that he had thought out three stories and two novels. The famous incident of the mock execution in Semenovsky Square, when Dostoevsky faced a firing squad, only to be reprieved at the last minute, followed on December 22nd. In Siberia, Dostoevsky’s only literary activity keeping a surreptitious notebook in which he noted the phrases and expressions used by his fellow convicts. He managed to give the notebook to one of the medical assistants who returned it to him upon his release. Its contents were used in House of the Dead, the book which described his prison camp experience.
This experience was horrific, not only because of the appalling physical conditions in which the convicts were housed, and the perpetual threat of flogging under which they lived, but Dostoevsky found himself, as a ‘gentleman’, totally rejected by the brutish peasant prisoners whose cause he had espoused and for whose sake, as a potential revolutionary, he was suffering exile and imprisonment. During the time of his imprisonment, Dostoevsky underwent a conversion experience in which his total dissolution with the peasantry was replaced by an almost mystical belief in their essential goodness. This was based upon an involuntary memory which came back to him from his childhood of an incident in which one of his father’s serfs, Marey, had comforted him when he was terrified. Although Dostoevsky suffered deeply from never being alone while in the prison camp, his emotional isolation and lack of companionship had the effect of turning his attention inward, and allowing his mind to wander in the past.
All through his four years in camp he had employed the technique of involuntary association, which probably served somewhat the same purpose as psychoanalysis or drug therapy in releasing repressed dreams and thereby relieving his psychic blocks and morbid fixations. This technique also served the additional and reassuring function of keeping alive his artistic faculties under conditions where he was forbidden to put pen to paper.3
Dostoevsky’s experience of penal servitude permanently influenced his view of human nature and hence permeated his novels. More particularly, his experience of seeing convicts who for years had been ruthlessly crushed suddenly break out and assert their own personalities, often in violent and irrational fashion, made him feel that individual self-expression or self-realization was a basic human need, a need which did not accord with the subordination of individuality to the collective demands of the State.4
Other creative people who experienced forced solitude included Edith Bone, M.D. (1889-1975), Christopher Burney (1917-1980), and Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827). Unlike Burney and Bone, Beethoven’s forced solitude was the result of his deafness which began in 1796 and continued for many years. His famous “Ninth Symphony” was written after his hearing loss had become more pronounced. In fact, after he played this symphony for the first time he actually cried because he was not able to hear the applause.5
Creativity inspiration is something which needs to be both encouraged and supported. Being alone is certainly a source of inspiration for various creative genius. In the case of some of these people they actually had difficulty interacting with other adults and some never had any type of intimate relationship and very few close friends. This may not be the type of solitude that every person can engage in, but it was certainly successful of some people.
End Notes
1) “Being Alone with One’s Thoughts” http://heideggerm1.blogspot.com/2011/06/being-alone-with-ones-thoughts.html (accessed 5/7/12)
2) “Being Alone with One’s Thoughts”
3) Joseph Frank Dostoevsky: The Years of Ordeal, 1850 to 1859 Five Volumes, (Princeton: 1983), Vol. II, p. 122
4) Anthony Storr Solitude: A Return to the Self (NY: Ballantine Books, 1988), p. 59
5) “Ludwig van Beethoven” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_van_Beethoven (accessed 5/7/12)
In an interview, Russian film director Andrei Tarkovsky [Андрей Арсеньевич Тарковский] (1932-1986) was asked what message he would like to leave for young people. Tarkovsky said that they should learn to love solitude and to be able to be alone with themselves. He believed that young people were carrying out noisy and aggressive actions in an effort not to be alone. He felt that all individuals must learn to be on his own as a child. This is not the same as being alone. He is referring to the idea of not becoming bored with oneself, which is sees as a very dangerous symptom, almost a disease.2
One thing which being alone can inspire, regardless of whether this isolation is voluntary or forced, is a sense of creativity. There are numerous examples of highly creative people who chose to be alone for extended periods of time and others who were forced into solitude as a result of imprisonment.
On Christmas Day 1849, Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky (1821-1881) began the long journey from St. Petersburg to Siberia where he was to spend the next four years in a prison camp. Together with other members of the Petrashevsky circle, a group of intellectuals, he had been arrested in April 1849, and had already spent eight months as a prisoner in the Peter and Paul fortress. During this initial period, he was in solitary confinement, and, at first, was not allowed books or writing materials. In spite of this, he discovered that he had inner resources which enabled him to tolerate captivity far better than he had initially expected. His arrest may even have saved him from a breakdown, rather than precipitating it; for there is evidence that his participation in an underground revolutionary organization had been preying on his mind during the previous winter, and had brought him to the edge of a collapse.
When, at the beginning of July, the prisoners were allowed to receive books from the fortress library Dostoevsky fell upon them. He also wrote to his brother, Mikhail, telling him that he had thought out three stories and two novels. The famous incident of the mock execution in Semenovsky Square, when Dostoevsky faced a firing squad, only to be reprieved at the last minute, followed on December 22nd. In Siberia, Dostoevsky’s only literary activity keeping a surreptitious notebook in which he noted the phrases and expressions used by his fellow convicts. He managed to give the notebook to one of the medical assistants who returned it to him upon his release. Its contents were used in House of the Dead, the book which described his prison camp experience.
This experience was horrific, not only because of the appalling physical conditions in which the convicts were housed, and the perpetual threat of flogging under which they lived, but Dostoevsky found himself, as a ‘gentleman’, totally rejected by the brutish peasant prisoners whose cause he had espoused and for whose sake, as a potential revolutionary, he was suffering exile and imprisonment. During the time of his imprisonment, Dostoevsky underwent a conversion experience in which his total dissolution with the peasantry was replaced by an almost mystical belief in their essential goodness. This was based upon an involuntary memory which came back to him from his childhood of an incident in which one of his father’s serfs, Marey, had comforted him when he was terrified. Although Dostoevsky suffered deeply from never being alone while in the prison camp, his emotional isolation and lack of companionship had the effect of turning his attention inward, and allowing his mind to wander in the past.
All through his four years in camp he had employed the technique of involuntary association, which probably served somewhat the same purpose as psychoanalysis or drug therapy in releasing repressed dreams and thereby relieving his psychic blocks and morbid fixations. This technique also served the additional and reassuring function of keeping alive his artistic faculties under conditions where he was forbidden to put pen to paper.3
Dostoevsky’s experience of penal servitude permanently influenced his view of human nature and hence permeated his novels. More particularly, his experience of seeing convicts who for years had been ruthlessly crushed suddenly break out and assert their own personalities, often in violent and irrational fashion, made him feel that individual self-expression or self-realization was a basic human need, a need which did not accord with the subordination of individuality to the collective demands of the State.4
Other creative people who experienced forced solitude included Edith Bone, M.D. (1889-1975), Christopher Burney (1917-1980), and Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827). Unlike Burney and Bone, Beethoven’s forced solitude was the result of his deafness which began in 1796 and continued for many years. His famous “Ninth Symphony” was written after his hearing loss had become more pronounced. In fact, after he played this symphony for the first time he actually cried because he was not able to hear the applause.5
Creativity inspiration is something which needs to be both encouraged and supported. Being alone is certainly a source of inspiration for various creative genius. In the case of some of these people they actually had difficulty interacting with other adults and some never had any type of intimate relationship and very few close friends. This may not be the type of solitude that every person can engage in, but it was certainly successful of some people.
End Notes
1) “Being Alone with One’s Thoughts” http://heideggerm1.blogspot.com/2011/06/being-alone-with-ones-thoughts.html (accessed 5/7/12)
2) “Being Alone with One’s Thoughts”
3) Joseph Frank Dostoevsky: The Years of Ordeal, 1850 to 1859 Five Volumes, (Princeton: 1983), Vol. II, p. 122
4) Anthony Storr Solitude: A Return to the Self (NY: Ballantine Books, 1988), p. 59
5) “Ludwig van Beethoven” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_van_Beethoven (accessed 5/7/12)
Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Unlucky at Cards
Every
year countless people from around the US and around the world travel to
Atlantic City, New Jersey, Las Vegas, Nevada, and various other locations in
order to have a relaxing vacation and hopefully win a large amount of money at
one of the many casinos. No matter how
much money a person wins at the casino, the “house” (casino) always has the
advantage.
However, many people try to overcome the
casino’s advantage by using some strategy which they believe will help them to
“beat the odds”. One of these strategies
is known as card counting. This involves counting the various cards which are
used in games such as blackjack. Knowing which cards have already been used and
which ones are left would certainly give the player an advantage. This
technique is not illegal, but if the casino believes that you are counting
cards they will more than likely ask you to leave.
Some people use various other techniques,
either legal or illegal to gain an advantage.
Since the casino can potentially lose a large amount of money they are
always looking for those people who attempting to manipulate the odds in favor
of the player. If illegal methods are
used, that person will be arrested and will likely be sent to jail.
The idea of gaining an advantage while
gambling is certainly nothing new. In
the play The Queen of Spades 1
by Alexander Sergeyevich Pushkin (1799-1837) this issue is dealt with. The main character is Hermann, an ethnic German,
who is an officer in the Imperial Russian Army.
Like many soldiers, his friends often play cards, but Hermann never
plays cards with them. One evening
another officer, Tomsky, tells Hermann a story about his grandmother who is now
an 87 year old countess.
Many years earlier, the countess had been
playing cards in France and initially had lost quite a bit of money. However, she then learned a secret regarding
three cards and apparently had won back all the money she had lost. There is no indication that Tomsky had
actually ever learned this secret nor is there any indication that he had used
the secret if he had learned it.
Even though Hermann is not a gambler, he
becomes obsessed with the idea of finding out what this secret is. In order to
do this he must meet the countess, but instead of approaching her directly he
finds out that she has a young ward named Lizavyeta Ivanovna. Hermann begins sending love letters to
Lizavyeta asking her to let him into the house.
Not surprisingly, Lizavyeta is taken by
the attention she has received from a Russian Army officer and invites him to
the house. Hermann aggressively
confronts the countess and demands that she tell him the secret of the three winning
cards. Initially, she tells him that the
secret is not real, but only a joke, but he does not believe her. He asks her a second time, but she remains
silent. At this point he decides to try again; however, this time he confronts
her with a pistol. At this point the
elderly countess dies of fright.
Hermann, who is now completely scared,
Lizavyeta confesses to her that he killed the countess. His only defense is that the pistol was not
loaded. Lizavyeta helps him to escape from the house even though she is annoyed
by the fact that his love letters were simply a rouse to allow him to meet the
countess.
He attends the countess’ funeral and is
terrified when the countess opens her eyes and looks at him as she is lying in
her coffin. Later that evening, her
ghost appears to him. The ghost tells him the secret of the three cards (three,
seven, and ace) and that he must play once each night and marry Lizavyeta. On the first night, he bets it all on the
three and wins. On the second night, he wins on the seven. On the third night,
he bets on the ace - but when cards are shown, he finds he has bet on the Queen
of Spades, rather than the ace, and loses everything. When the Queen appears to
wink at him, he flees in terror.
Hermann goes mad and is committed to an
asylum.
He is installed in Room 17 at the
Obukhov hospital; he answers no questions, but merely mutters with unusual
rapidity: 'Three, seven, ace! Three, seven, queen!' 2
There is a tradition in Russian literature
that negative actions on the part of a particular character are ultimately
connected with them going insane. This
can be seen in Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky (1821-1881) and
several other novels. Hermann’s actions were not only immoral, but illegal and instead
of benefitting from the information he received, he ends up going insane and
losing everything. This would definitely
qualify him as being unlucky at cards.
End Notes
1) “The Queen of Spades” http://www.classicreader.com/book/2154/1/
(English translation) [accessed 4/30/12]
2) “The Queen of Spades” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Queen_of_Spades_(story)
(accessed 4/30/12)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)